Do we really have compassion fatigue?


Hello Reader,

We talk a lot about compassion fatigue in animal welfare. It is real. Rescue workers become exhausted, angry, cynical, or leave the field entirely.

Sometimes the animals aren’t what’s wearing people down. It’s the people. The public has become increasingly hard to handle. The current environment in this country encourages entitlement, and people are saying and doing whatever they want with no consequences.

It’s being screamed at because you can’t waive a fee, return an animal that has already been adopted while the original owner has been in jail. It’s being blamed for an animal someone else failed. It’s hearing “if you really cared” from someone asking you to solve a problem they created.

It’s being attacked online by people who know absolutely nothing about the situation but have apparently earned an advanced degree in shelter management from Facebook University.

It’s irresponsible owners. It’s unrealistic expectations. It’s bullying. It’s internal drama. It’s other animal welfare organizations tearing each other apart.

It’s expected to remain endlessly kind and patient while others are allowed to behave however they want because “you work with the public.” This part we have changed, we no longer allow our staff to be abused by the public, we ask them to be reasonable, if they can’t handle that we have our local police force on speed dial.

Maybe some of what we’ve been calling compassion fatigue is actually people fatigue. That’s important because you can’t fix the wrong problem. We cannot control how people act in most cases.

A pizza party isn’t going to fix abusive customers. A self-care webinar isn’t going to fix toxic management. “Remember your why” won’t fix chronic understaffing. Telling burned-out employees to practice resilience won’t fix an organization that refuses to protect them. We must protect our staff, if they know we support them they will keep coming back.

If we want good people to stay in animal welfare, we need to stop assuming their compassion is what’s broken.

Sometimes they’re simply exhausted from being treated badly. I think we need to talk about that a whole lot more.

Roxanne

Thank you,

for following, reading, and being part of the solution to the animal crisis. You are appreciated.

Roxanne

Now on Substack

Follow me:

605 Mango Tree Dr, Edgewater, FL 32132
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Shelter Shift

If you've been in this world long enough, you know sheltering isn't just about housing animals. It's about problem-solving, adapting, and constantly working to do better for the animals in your care. And let's be honest, it's not easy. Overcrowding, limited resources, and burnout can overwhelm even the most passionate among us. Sign up and get practical, no-nonsense insights on intake, adoptions, staff retention, and post-adoption follow-up, straight from someone who has run these systems.

Read more from The Shelter Shift

Hi Reader I had a couple of different emails planned for tonight. I started writing and everything sounded hollow. I walked away and came back, but first I took a stroll through my instagram messages. It is no secret if you follow me on instagram I am disenchanted with social media, I have pretty much quit posting on Facebook and TikTok is a seventh circle of hell I am not interested in participating in, I am not interested in being a "creator" I am interested in helping animals, shelter...

Dog parks, lots of visitors and visits to Home Depot are a hard No. Hello Friends, We put together a one-page guide for new adopters covering the first 72 hours after bringing a dog home, what to do, what to skip, and how to set the dog up to actually decompress instead of spiral. Here is the complete blog post. It's the stuff most adopters need to hear and don't: keep the world small, watch before you train, secure the exits, don't take anything personally. Short enough to read in two...

The message is incorrect. All of us know it. You have probably seen the coverage. Save rates are up. More shelters going no-kill. The national numbers are trending positive. And if you are working inside a shelter right now, you are probably reading those headlines and feeling like you are losing your mind. Because your kennel is full. Your staff is burned out. Your intake doesn't stop. And the animals coming through your door are harder to place than ever. You are not imagining it. The data...